Reflections on what’s changed (or not) in the care sector

Sue Toole worked as an Assistant Care and Support Adviser on our adviceline in 2025-26. Here Sue reflects on some of the differences she has observed in social care after 45 years of social work and her own family experiences.

Having recently worked on the adviceline here at Care Rights UK, I am struck by some of the differences I have seen and heard in social care, after 45 years of social work, combined with the family experiences of my Mom’s care for 14 years in a Birmingham care home.   

“One of the things that seems to be so obviously missing is partnership working. I am thinking about families, relatives and care home staff here.” 

Family involvement in care

You might think that care staff would welcome engagement from families, who spend hours in the care home with their relatives. After all, it can relieve the very tight pressures care staff are under on an almost constant basis. Relatives that take their loved ones out, for example, must free up some time and capacity. Relatives who support their loved ones to eat, dress and take an interest in activities used to be welcomed by care staff. Sometimes, they still are and work together with staff to support their relatives.  

Sadly, callers to our adviceline often share that some staff  resent relatives “interfering” with care routines, seeing their involvement as a clash of responsibilities and boundaries. In extreme cases, relatives are even restricted or excluded from visiting by the care home, a practice that Care Rights UK encourages relatives to challenge under Article 8 of the Human Rights Act – which is about your right to a family life. 

I contrast this with, for example, the care worker at my Mom’s care home, who phoned me to ask if I wanted to come with them on a day trip to the seaside. This gave Mom the confidence to say yes to this offer. Together, staff, relatives and about 20 residents had a fabulous day out at the seaside. I was so impressed by the planning of the care staff . They had, very discreetly, brought a whole change of clothing for every resident, plus a variety of meds, all sorts of snacks to keep people going until they arrived at the seaside, and ramps and chairs for those who needed them. As we broke up into smaller groups, this allowed for a personal and fun day out, working together to support our loved ones. Nothing was getting in the way of my Mom’s desire for some fish and chips! 

Of course, not all families are harmonious, and I fully appreciate the difficulties care staff have when family members are estranged from each other, and in fundamental disagreement about their loved ones’ care. 

Exclusion from care planning 

The lack of joint working shows up when it comes to care planning and care plans. Many callers to our adviceline have not seen a care plan, not been invited to care planning meetings or been engaged in any way. Yet they know their loved ones well, have maybe cared for them for years prior to their move into residential care and can make a significant contribution to helping care staff know and understand their personal needs, likes and dislikes.  They can also, when included, correct mistakes often made at initial assessment and act as the trusted voice to speak on their behalf. 

I well remember Mom’s initial care review document. It had 39 spelling mistakes and contained gems such as “Mrs X chooses her choices”. Without family involvement to help share relevant info, and correct inaccuracies, the home would have had a very poor picture to work with.  

I would like to think care records and planning is more systematic and has improved since then but am not convinced. Some of our callers tell us about inaccuracies in care notes.  Callers have told us of hours of quality time they have spent exclusively with their relatives, despite care notes recording staff interventions, washing, medication, being taken into the garden, that just didn’t happen.  

The need for training and investment in the social care workforce

As a young inspector, some years ago, I remember talking with care staff about care records. They were very reluctant to write anything much, frightened of getting it wrong, not understanding the point or purpose. They rarely had the skills, training or support that would help them. It seems that more support is still needed here.  

Come on, Andy, let’s get a coherent, competent set of quality standards for care, a training framework for care workers, in social and health care, and pay them a decent rate for doing a good job!!

Next
Next

Why we need a Cool Homes Plan for social care